I think this is the fatal flaw in Obama’s class-warfare tax plan.
Initially, high earners will push their tax deductions to the absolute limit (no, I don’t think they’re doing that now).
… then they’ll just re-create tax shelter devices reminiscent of the pre-Reagan days (e.g. rental properties; gas, oil, timber partnerships)
… and finally, they’ll take their bank accounts to safe havens.
A couple of vignettes bring the dynamics to life.
* * * * *
According to FBN’s John Stossel …
New York billionaire Tom Golisano isn’t stupid.
With $3,000 and one employee, he started a business that processes paychecks for companies. He created 13,000 jobs.
Then New York state hiked the income tax on millionaires.
“It was the straw that broke the camel’s back,” he says.
“Not that I like to throw the number around, but my personal income tax last year would’ve been $13,800 a day. Would you like to write a check for $13,800 a day to a state government, as opposed to moving to another state where there’s no state income tax or very low state income tax?
He established residence in Florida, which has no personal income tax.
* * * * *
Maryland created a special tax on rich people that was supposed to bring in $106 million. Instead, the state lost $257 million.
Former Gov. Robert Ehrlich, who is running again for his old job, says: “It reminds me of Charlie Brown. Charlie Brown was always surprised when Lucy pulled the football away. And they’re always surprised in Washington and state capitals when the dollars never come in.”
Some of Maryland’s rich left the state.
“They’re out of here. These people aren’t stupid,” Ehrlich says.
* * * * *
Donald Trump, who knows something about making money, says of course the rich will leave when hit with higher taxes.
“I know these people,” he told me.
“They’re international people. Whether they live here or live in a place like Switzerland doesn’t really matter to them.”
You haven’t left, I told him.
“I haven’t left yet. … Look, the rich people are going to leave. And other people are going to leave. You’re going to end up with lots of people that don’t produce. And then that’s the spiral. That’s the end.”
* * * * *
Excerted from John Stossel, Taxing the Rich, September 29, 2010
http://www.realclearpolitics.com/articles/2010/09/29/taxing_the_rich_107350.html
