Study: Chances of dying are greater if your doctor is over 60.

And, some advice for hedging your bets.
=======

Researchers at Harvard scoured the records of 730,000 patients treated between 2011 and 2014 by more than 18,800 hospital-based internists (now called “hospitalists”).

The results were originally published in the BMJ (British Medical Journal) and recapped in StudyFinds:

Patients are 1.3% more likely to die when treated by doctors over the age of 60, than if they’re treated by doctors under 40.

That translates to one additional death for every 77 patients under the care of a doctor over 60.

clip_image001

What’s going on?

==========

The common explanation: Older doctors have the obvious benefit of experience. But, younger doctors are more current on medical research and technology … and, they have more physical stamina to handle the heavy patient-loads that are increasingly common these days.

==========

Personal anecdote #1

We have a friend who was diagnosed with cancer.

Picked a gray haired doctor who was acclaimed by Washingtonian Magazine and practiced at a local hospital,

The results: Cancer wasn’t arrested and the friend eventually shifted to doctors at Johns Hopkins who stated bluntly: “We would have had more treatment options if you had come to us first.”

Apparently, older local doctor was a bit old-school regarding research and techniques.

========

Personal anecdote #1

A doctor friend of ours has always advocated going to a teaching hospital (think: Georgetown, Hopkins) for serious medical conditions.

We took his advice when Kathy was diagnosed with breast cancer.

Man, are we glad we did.

Her team of doctors (and nurse practitioners) ranged in age from 30 to 65 … several taught in GU’s med school … her surgeon and cardiologist were women in their 30s … her oncologist had plenty of gray hair … our point-person was a nurse practitioner in her early 30s … there was often a swarm of residents interacting with the docs – both taking notes and offering their point-of-view.

My point: Kathy had a mix of young and old docs who seemed to respect each other’s opinions and worked well together … keeping their patient in clear focus.

Today, Kathy is officially classified as a cancer survivor.

========

Lessons learned

It’s not a matter of old or young.

Some older docs keep pace; some young docs throttle down when they get their degrees.

The trick is forging a team that blends the experience of the young docs with the experience of the older ones.

You get that at most teaching hospitals.

So, get you tonsils out at the local hospital.

But take my friend’s advice: go to a teaching hospital for serious medical conditions.

And, oh yeah, don’t pick your doc based local magazine surveys ……

==========

#HomaFiles

Follow on Twitter @KenHoma            >> Latest Posts

==========

One Response to “Study: Chances of dying are greater if your doctor is over 60.”

  1. John Carpenter Says:

    This is an issue we face across the cultural board. For example airline pilot mandatory retirement age was just (2009) raised from 60 to 65, but they are forced out then. Airline pilots are handsomely (overly??) compensated during their working years to prepare them for this. Because of this policy the airline industry looses a lot of experience, but as a qualified Air Transport Pilot myself with a few decades of flight time, I support it. However, a program where youthful and experienced pilots were both assigned as a team, with appropriate (read “the old guy does not automatically have seniority”) agreements on how the shots are called in the cockpit, could be a beneficial alternative. As America ages healthy 60+ year old workers remain in the workforce beyond the time in 1960’s-70’s they would have retired. This could be a good thing but rules and more importantly, culture, have to change to reflect the reality of changed physical and mental capabilities. If we can do this we can leverage our new healthier 60+ generation,

    Hmmmm. I wonder how this would apply to politics????

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s