Complying with CDC guidelines may be cost prohibitive and logistically impossible.
=============
One of my biggest coronavirus concerns has been the school-shut-down impact on kids … both socially and educationally.
Since children are negligibly hurt by the virus (i.e. lower infection vulnerability, minor or no symptoms when infected, low transmission-forward rate), I’ve been a advocate for re-opening schools ASAP.
I’ve been implicitly assuming that “cleaning” the schools’ environment would be no big deal … just move the desks further apart and double down on nighttime deep-cleaning.
I’ve been glossing over the economics and the logistics…
=============
According to US News …
Adhering to CDC safety recommendations for reopening is becoming an overwhelming problem and many school districts are considering a continuation of distance learning.
What’s the problem?
For openers, it’s estimated that schools may need to spend an additional $500 per student in order to cover costs associated with:
- Cleaning supplies: hand sanitizer, disinfectant wipes.
- Protective equipment: gloves, masks
- Additional custodial staff to do the extra cleaning
- School nurses (at least one per school)
- Bus aides (to do temperature checks and maintain separation)
- Additional teachers (or teacher aides) to enable smaller class sizes
The additional expenses for an average school district of about 4,000 students could total around $2 million.
And, that doesn’t count any required capital improvements to provide enough working faucets for frequent handwashing … or upgraded HVA systems to improve air quality and filtration.
============
Then, there are logistical hurdles…
For example, 55% of K-to- 12 students take a bus to school.
Bus fleets would need to quadruple in size to safely transport 100% of students under COVID-19 distancing guidelines.
And, of course, each bus needs a driver … and, drivers are always in short supply.
=============
Maybe reopening the schools isn’t as easy as I thought.
=============
Thanks to MKH for feeding the lead.
June 22, 2020 at 11:16 am |
Prof. Homa, I’m a MSB ‘12 and a Frequent reader of your blog. This post, and your post on the “summer slide”, resonated with me. I run a company that invests in and advises education innovators (‘EdTech’). My cofounder and I published the following ideas on how school facilities can change to enable “distance teaching” rather than “distance learning. I’d appreciate your comments, pros and cons, on the strategy: https://www-nydailynews-com.cdn.ampproject.org/c/s/www.nydailynews.com/opinion/ny-oped-reimagine-schools-to-reopen-them-20200609-sdnycurlnncuhkq3hdz3qszhti-story.html?outputType=amp
Ash Kaluarachchi
https://www.linkedin.com/in/ashanthaik