Posts Tagged ‘billionaires’

Millionaires pay a lower tax rate than $50K teachers … not!

September 21, 2011

The press were abuzz yesterday debunking O’s key premise that millionaires pay taxes at a lower rate than teachers making $50,000.

Yesterday, we showed that a married  teacher with 2 kids who earns $50,000 pays at a 5.5% rate.  Even if you add 7.65 in payroll taxes to that, the resulting  13.15% is still less than a millionaire who pays only capital gains taxes at 15%.

That was a micro analysis.

The WSJ presented the macro analysis:

In 2008, the last year for which such data are available, the IRS reports that those who made more than $1 million in adjusted gross income paid an average income tax rate of 23.3%.

That’s slightly lower than the 24.1% rate paid by those making between $500,000 and $1 million, probably because the richest are like Mr. Buffett and earn more from capital gains and dividends.

The rate for a relative handful of the rich — 400 people — fell to 18%.

But nearly all millionaires still paid a rate that is more than twice the 8.9% average rate paid by those earning between $50,000 and $100,000, and more than three times the 7.2% average rate paid by those earning less than $50,000.

The larger point is that the claim that CEOs are routinely paying lower tax rates than their secretaries is Omaha hokum.

image

I think the President should modify his Buffett Rule to read: anybody who earns more than $1 million … and who has accumulated wealth greater than $25 billion  … and who plans to bequeath practically all of his estate to a pal’s “foundation” shall pay an effective income tax rate of 90% … unless he /she whines that they’re being  coddled, in which case the tax rate escalates to 100%.

My real recommendation: limit the charitable estate exemption to $1 million so that Buffet has to fork about half of his estate over to the government … that’ll keep him from bring coddled in the grave.

>> Latest Posts